Former President Donald Trump introduced an audacious 20-point plan to address the horrible continuing war between Israel and now Hamas. His proposal would further assure the release of Israeli captives now held in Palestinian areas. At a press briefing following the President’s announcement, federal officials touted the proposal. It provides a step-by-step plan linking military withdrawals, hostage releases, and the establishment of a new multilateral monitoring apparatus. Trump’s plan is intended as a realistic starting point towards peace. Lastly, it urges Arab and Muslim states to be more proactive in finding a solution given their interest in the outcome.
The announcement comes as violence in the region continues to spike. All of them know that both sides are under intense pressure to come to an agreement. Just as significantly, Trump underscored a need for cooperation on the international stage. He suggested establishing an independent body to carry out the new plan, with himself as czar, apparently, at the helm. The participation of other heavyweights, such as former UK Prime Minister Tony Blair, would help build support for the initiative.
Key Elements of Trump’s Proposal
Trump’s plan is painfully short on details, but here are 4 essential ideas to stabilize Gaza and secure long-term peace. The project is framed as an effort to produce a new “technocratic” leadership in Gaza. Though controversial, this leadership would work separately from Hamas and the PA. This temporary authority would be responsible for governing day-to-day affairs and laying the foundation for good governance following the conflict.
Additionally, Trump underscored the need for Arab and Muslim countries to be empowered to contribute to holding Hamas accountable. In response, he claimed that these countries have provided written guarantees to demilitarize Gaza in a swift manner. The proposal is a solid reminder that any effort towards durable peace must be led and owned by regional powers.
“Arab and Muslim nations need to be allowed the chance to fulfill these commitments of dealing with Hamas. They have to deal with them because they were the one group that we have not dealt with.” – Donald Trump
Trump’s main point was that Israel should not withdraw any more troops until Hamas is broken down and demilitarized. He emphasized that these actions are inextricably connected. He added that, for the foreseeable future, Israel will be responsible for security in the area.
Palestinian Leadership and Responsibility
A crucial aspect of Trump’s plan involves the selection of Palestinian leadership by the proposed international body rather than by the Palestinian people themselves. This unpopular and highly contested strategy seeks to create a more rational and accountable polity in Gaza.
Trump emphasized that Palestinians must take responsibility for their future, challenging them to reject terrorism and embrace peace. He promised them that his plan provides them a chance to influence their fate for the best.
“I challenge the Palestinians to take responsibility for their destiny because that’s what we’re giving them. We’re giving them responsibility for their destiny, to fully condemn and prohibit terrorism and earn their way to a brighter future.” – Donald Trump
The former president’s claim raises some important questions about Palestinian self-determination and governance. Critics fear that such external control would erode local control and autonomy.
Netanyahu’s Support and Concerns
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu expressed support for Trump’s plan, asserting that it aligns with Israel’s objectives in the conflict. He pointed out that the proposal would ensure the return of all Israeli hostages, while removing Hamas’s military power and political control.
Netanyahu added that the need to ensure Gaza does not pose a future threat to Israel again was paramount. He further validated Israel’s deep-seated insecurities within the tumultuous region. He went further than that, cautioning that serious consequences would be in store if Hamas refuses or seeks to subvert the plan.
“If Hamas rejects your plan, Mr. President, or if they supposedly accept it and then basically do everything to counter it, then Israel will finish the job by itself.” – Benjamin Netanyahu
The Israeli leaders words illustrate how hard a line the Israeli officials are believing. They view military action as a necessary option should diplomatic efforts fail.
