An independent investigation has found serious failings in the residential care provided for adults with learning disabilities on the Isle of Man. These findings highlight the critical need to transform the care system. Cordis Bright specialists wrote the report. In doing so, they shine a light on a broken system that tends to focus on just availability, not suitability, leading to these children going to inappropriate placements in one of the island’s 17 residential homes.
The review indicated that individuals are placed in facilities based on what is available, rather than matching their specific needs. This practice has shocked families and advocates alike, and for decades families have been fighting this flawed system. Fran Tinkler, Director of Manx Mencap, stated that the findings of the report confirm experiences families have encountered for years.
Tinkler commented, “The report confirmed what families had experienced for years.” She elaborated that the services could be described as “fragmented, under-resourced, and may not meet the needs of people with learning disabilities and their families.” This sentiment, as providers often hear today, is reminiscent of past concerns related to the lack of sufficient care and support provided to this vulnerable population.
Unfortunately, the report did highlight that in many places these “inappropriate workarounds” have become standard operating procedure. For instance, one residential home reportedly lacks basic amenities such as Wi-Fi, which has raised questions about the overall quality of life for residents.
Teresa Cope, Chief Executive of the organisation that runs these care services, accepted the findings. Perhaps most importantly, she conveyed a genuine sense of urgency and resolve to improve things. “This must be the moment that promises turn into progress, supported by proper investment, clear accountability, and timelines for change,” she added.
This review went further, shining a much needed spotlight on the hazards that currently exist within the system. Mismatched placements may lead to issues. They can lead to the highest need people being placed in the same setting as people with greater capacity to be independent. This chilling scenario would beget a dangerous world where those with lesser needs experience “undue burdens.”
